Same Old Place

662 Centre St, Jamaica Plain, MA 02130 Order now
Hero image

The Best New York Style Pizza


Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Same Old Place Reviews on Grubhub


Top Reviewer
They were very kind and professional to call me ahead of time to let me know when the oven turns on and when it would be ready (I made an order for pizza first thing in the morning). They called a second time to let me know about another thing about my order, which I really appreciated. Both times they were friendly. The driver was also very kind. Will order from again.


Top Reviewer
The order was incredibly quick. But I order Sicilian slices in the menu but receive plain slices. It would have been good to receive a call advising that Sicilian slices were not available at the time and not gotten charged more for them rather than a regular slice.


1 review
Delivery was quick and the food was good. Garlic bread was not so good but the main courses were solid. Also they hooked us up with extra garlic bread which was nice but it didn't make the bread taste better which wasn't so nice but would def order from again.


Top Reviewer
Great pizza and crust. Toppings were abundant and well distributed. It is thinner pizza with a droop if that is your style. I asked for a side of marinara for dipping in comments and they came through strong with a big container of it. Would buy from again.


3 reviews
Bad beginning, but ended up being great. The driver initially took the wrong pizza, but after contacting GrubHub and talking to the manager they sent the correct pizza!
Great customer service! And the pizza was great too!

Reviews from

Same Old Place Reviews on Seamless


1 review
Even though my order was an hour late, when I called the restaurant Wilson quickly got on the phone with his driver. He then explained they had been totally slammed, down a driver, and my food was minutes away. He asked me to call back and ask for him if my food was cold, and it wasnt! The driver also apologized for being late. The good service made up for the lateness, food was the same as it always is, great.


1 review
Awesome food and will buy ahain


Top Reviewer
Good pizza as always

About us

American, Calzones, Dinner, Hamburgers, Italian, Lunch Specials, Pizza, Sandwiches
Delivery: 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM
Takeout: 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM

The Same Old Place is a family owned and operated establishment that has been a Jamaica Plain mainstay since 1977. Fred Ciampa, Owner, realized his dream of owning his own "Pizza Parlor" at the tender age of fourteen. He agressively pursued his dream and at nineteen became protege to the founder of Papa Ginos Inc. In 1963. From that point on, Fred Opened several successful Pizza sub shops and became a local pizza legend. Fred continues to put out Boston's Best "New York Style" Pizza. Stop by for a slice! Same Old Place, Often Imitated, never duplicated!